Libya: Four Cases of Disappearance and Arbitrary Detention Demand Urgent Action
The disappearance of a university professor and his colleague in western Libya, alongside the reported arrest of a journalist and his brother in the south, raises serious concerns about enforced disappearance,
arbitrary detention, and the lack of effective judicial oversight. The cases underscore the urgent need to establish the four men’s whereabouts, ensure their safety, and hold those responsible for any violations accountable.
Background
On the afternoon of 4 October 2026, media professor Mohammed Sharaf Al-Din Al-Fitouri and his colleague, Abu Bakr Al-Jarari, lost contact with their families after leaving the Libyan Academy for Graduate Studies in Janzour on their way home. According to local reports citing Al-Fitouri’s family, no responsible authority has provided information about their whereabouts. His daughter said that he is ill and requires regular medication and medical care. The circumstances of the two men’s disappearance and the identity of those responsible remain unknown.
In a separate incident, journalist Mustafa Khalifa Al-Sheikh, 38, and his brother Mohammed, 41, were reportedly arrested on 22 September 2026 when armed men raided their home in Al-Barkat, south of Ghat. The operation was attributed to fighters affiliated with the Libyan Arab Armed Forces (LAAF). Reports have linked the arrests to their brother Bashir Al-Sheikh, a media professional and outspoken critic of authorities in eastern Libya. The available information does not establish the precise legal grounds for the arrests or confirm the brothers’ current place of detention.
The two cases have emerged amid persistent concerns over arbitrary detention, secret detention facilities, and limited judicial oversight in Libya. Over the past decade, hundreds of people have reportedly been detained because of their political or tribal affiliations, held without a legal basis, or subjected to grossly unfair trials. Journalists, activists, protesters, and social media users have also faced detention in connection with their peaceful activities or expression.
Concerns over detention conditions are compounded by reports of torture, ill-treatment, and denial of medical care. Between 23 August and 9 September 2026, 30 people were reportedly executed in eastern Libya following military trials described as deeply flawed, some of which reportedly involved confessions extracted under torture. These cases have intensified scrutiny of due process, the treatment of detainees, and accountability for violations by security bodies and armed groups.
Institutional Position
The disappearance of individuals and the concealment of detainees’ whereabouts expose them to torture and other abuses while denying their families basic information and legal protection. Libya’s political fragmentation and competing security structures do not absolve authorities or armed groups exercising control over detention facilities of their responsibility to protect detainees and ensure effective judicial oversight.
These cases reflect wider patterns of arbitrary detention and intimidation targeting journalists, activists, and political opponents in Libya. Lawyers face obstacles accessing clients and case files, while threats against judges, prosecutors, and attorneys undermine judicial independence and accountability. Detention must not serve as a tool to punish political affiliation, silence criticism, or restrict peaceful expression and assembly. Anyone held solely for exercising these rights must be released.
Reports of torture, ill-treatment, and denial of medical care further underscore the need for accountability. Between 23 August and 9 September 2026, 30 people were reportedly executed in eastern Libya following deeply flawed military trials, some involving confessions allegedly extracted under torture. Executions following proceedings that fail to meet international fair-trial standards raise serious concerns about arbitrary deprivation of life and the use of coerced evidence.
All death sentences arising from proceedings that fail to meet international standards must be reviewed, and executions halted pending that review. Evidence obtained through torture must be excluded, and defendants must have access to legal counsel and a genuine opportunity to challenge the charges before an independent and impartial tribunal. No accusation of terrorism or threat to state security justifies torture, secret detention, or the denial of due process.
Applicable Legal Framework
The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) prohibits arbitrary arrest and detention (Article 9), torture and cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment (Article 7), and guarantees humane treatment of detainees (Article 10), the right to life (Article 6), fair-trial guarantees (Article 14), and freedom of expression (Article 19). These protections require lawful grounds for detention, access to judicial review and legal counsel, and safeguards against abuse and arbitrary deprivation of liberty.
Where enforced disappearance is suspected, authorities must establish the individuals’ fate and whereabouts, investigate the circumstances, and ensure effective remedies and accountability. Investigations must examine the responsibility of both direct perpetrators and officials who ordered, authorized, or facilitated the violations, while protecting families, witnesses, and lawyers from intimidation or reprisals.
Demands Aligned with International Human Rights Principles
|
Demand |
Relevant International Human Rights Standard |
|
Immediately disclose the whereabouts of the four men, ensure their safety and contact with their families and lawyers, and provide Al-Fitouri with necessary medication and independent medical care. |
ICCPR Arts. 6, 7, 9, 10 |
|
Release anyone detained without lawful grounds or solely for peaceful expression or activity; disclose the legal basis for continued detention and ensure prompt judicial review. |
ICCPR Arts. 9, 14, 19 |
|
Conduct prompt, independent investigations into both cases; preserve evidence, identify those responsible, and protect families, witnesses, and lawyers from reprisals. |
ICCPR Arts. 2(3), 6, 7, 9 |
|
End secret detention, maintain official detainee registers subject to judicial oversight, enforce release orders, and permit independent visits to all detention facilities. |
ICCPR Arts. 9, 10 |
|
Review politically motivated prosecutions before independent and impartial courts, exclude evidence obtained through torture, and guarantee fair-trial rights in all proceedings. |
ICCPR Arts. 7, 14 |
|
Halt executions following unfair trials, review the relevant convictions, and ensure strict compliance with international safeguards on the death penalty. |
ICCPR Arts. 6, 7, 14 |
|
Require the Office of the Attorney General, relevant authorities, and armed groups to cooperate with investigations and submit detention facilities to effective judicial oversight; urge UNSMIL, OHCHR, and relevant international mechanisms to monitor the cases and support accountability. |
ICCPR Arts. 2(3), 6, 7, 9, 14 |
The authorities must establish the fate and whereabouts of the four men, ensure their safety, and release anyone held arbitrarily. No political settlement or reconciliation process can substitute for accountability for enforced disappearance, torture, and unlawful detention.
Women Journalists Without Chains
Geneva, Switzerland – October 10, 2026


En
Ar